Subject: Re: Barret: a couple of re-writes
From: Barrett Brown <barriticus@gmail.com>
Date: 5/27/11, 14:44
To: Christopher Arsenault <Christopher.Arsenault@aljazeera.net>
CC: Nasir Yousafzai Khan <nasir.khan@aljazeera.net>, Hashem Said <saidh@aljazeera.net>

I'm sorry, but what you're proposing is not at all appropriate. For one thing, it's not really about data mining; it's about a classified military apparatus that makes use of data mining in addition to a large number of other capabilities. And victims of data mining don't know they've been data mined; data mining is done secretly and on a massive scale. It's not something like identify theft. Why this is a problem is made quite clear throughout the piece.

As for "humanizing" and making the piece more "punchy," that's not something I do, as I think it's bad for journalism. The "pull" in this case comes from the fact that I am revealing a massive, advanced surveillance apparatus which the U.S. is using to monitor a great portion of the Arab world, and that I am explaining this as someone who has been leading a crowd-sourced investigation into the intelligence contracting industry for several months. Quotes from other privacy advocates would add nothing of substance to the piece; obviously they'd be opposed to it for the same reasons I've already noted.

I'm sure you have strong opinions about how

On Thu, May 26, 2011 at 9:00 AM, Christopher Arsenault <Christopher.Arsenault@aljazeera.net> wrote:
Hi Barrett,
 
I hope this message finds you well. My name is Chris Arsenault and I am an editor with Al jazeera's english language website. I just read your first piece on data mining. While I really like the investigative angle and the research, I think the piece lacks pull and will need some additions and re-writes.
 
To over-simplify, I am left thinking: Who cares about all these e-mails and junk after I read it. You need to humanise the issue a little bit. And explain clearly to someone who isn't familiar with the issue why they should care about this. As it stands, the piece reads too much like a technical document.
 
I am hoping you can talk to some privacy advocates (start with the ACLU and go from there) aout why this is scarey, and then have them comment on particular aspects of the case. Ideally, I would like you to talk to someone who is a victim of data mining. Please do at least 4 solid interviews.
 
At one point you list a bunch of companies and then a bunch of services provided. Some of this information could be interesting, but you need to walk the reader through why it is important.
 
Take a look at some of the stuff the Guardian and other papers have done with Wikileaks.
 
We are really excited about the investigation and look forward to running it. However, let's really make it punchy.
 
thanks
let me know when you can send a new version.
 
chris
 
Chris Arsenault  Journalist  |  Web & New Media
Al Jazeera English Channel |  PO Box 23127  |  Doha  |  Qatar
M: +974 331-23107 Email address: christopher.arsenault@aljazeera.net


Notice: This email is intended only for the use of the individual or entity named above and may contain information that is confidential and privileged. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this email is strictly prohibited. Opinions, conclusions and other information in this message that do not relate to the official business of our firm shall be understood as neither given nor endorsed by it.



--
Regards,

Barrett Brown
512-560-2302