Re: your column
Subject: Re: your column
From: Barrett Brown <barriticus@gmail.com>
Date: 7/14/10, 21:18
To: Clark Robinson <robinsonchicago@gmail.com>

Yeah, let's definitely keep that in mind. We can easily find other Russian analysts through Mark, anyway. I'll also ask Andrew Sullivan for suggestions, as well as Juan Cole; both of them know bloggers in the Mid East and elsewhere.

On Tue, Jul 13, 2010 at 5:23 PM, Clark Robinson <robinsonchicago@gmail.com> wrote:
Great article by Jeremy.  It reminded me that one thing we may want to look into for Project PM is finding international bloggers, particularly in Africa, Asia and South America who blog in English and might be widget-worthy.  Some time back when this notion first occurred to me, I spent some time Googling, trying to find Africans who blog in English; I thought there might be some in the English-colonized nations, but all I found was Americans and Europeans who live in Africa, often temporarily, which was not what I had in mind.  But you may have connections from your Dar es Salaam experiences that would enable finding African writers. Also, the bike guys might help in this regard.



 Tue, Jul 13, 2010 at 4:03 PM, Barrett Brown <barriticus@gmail.com> wrote:
Also, Clark, Jeremy Sapienza is starting to do some freelancing, starting with the CS Monitor, and I'm going to help him expand into other venues in the coming months.

http://www.csmonitor.com/Commentary/Opinion/2010/0713/Uganda-bombings-Obama-mustn-t-meddle-in-Somalia


On Tue, Jul 13, 2010 at 4:58 PM, Clark Robinson <robinsonchicago@gmail.com> wrote:
Hello, Prof. Silverman,

My name's Clark Robinson; I am working with Barrett Brown on Project PM. I am a retired lawyer helping him with administrative tasks.

Here is a link to our group blog, http://workshoppm.blogspot.com/ .  This is not Project PM itself, but is a planning forum for those of us interested in developing Project PM.  If you click way back in the "older posts," you will find a list of links to various articles Barrett has written which provide interesting background for the project.  A couple of these links also give a foretaste of his book coming out later this year (the ones with the names of NYT pundits in the link). Based on these and some other sections of this book I have seen in draft, I expect it to trigger some heated public discussion about the role of punditry in our nation's affairs.  With regard to Project PM,  I particularly recommend Barrett's earlier articles in Skeptical Inquirer, listed on the Workshop blog.

Some writers who have expressed interest in being a part of Project PM  include journalist Michael Hastings, blogger Allison Kilkenny ( Unreported ); blogger Mark Adomanis ( On Russia ), and Charles Johnson, with whom you are familiar. A recent recruit is Mano Singham, a physicist, who is  Director of  the University Center for Innovation in Teaching and Education  at Case Western Reserve University; his blog is at http://blog.case.edu/singham/ .

You will also see on the Workshop blog that we are talking about applying the underlying concepts of Project PM to charitable work and to journalism about science, and some of the posts on the workshop blog relate to those sub-projects.

Feel free to contact either Barrett or myself with any questions you have about Project PM. 

Clark Robinson
Chicago
217 722-8680




On Tue, Jul 13, 2010 at 11:50 AM, Barrett Brown <barriticus@gmail.com> wrote:
Henry-

Thanks for getting in touch. The project is indeed still being prepared, and in fact has expanded in scope quite a bit. We would love to have you involved.

Below, I've pasted a concise description of how our proposed media network would operate. In addition, we are also putting together a parallel network which is to serve as a sort of distributed online think-tank, one which will tackle several related projects, all of which concern improving information flow in order to better organize various methods of collaboration.

We also have some other materials that might help to bring you up to speed on what we've been doing and what our plans are at this point, and we'll get those to you soon. Also feel free to call me and I can fill you in on generals. I have copied my associate Clark Robinson on this; he is currently acting as my second-in-command.

***

Information flow is fundamental to the success of every manner of human collaboration. Nonetheless, the processes by which information is gathered, handled, transferred, and acted upon receive far less attention than is warranted. The purpose of Project PM is to change this dynamic by developing new techniques with which to more efficiently conduct information.
Because the great preponderance of information crucial to the success of a representative government is transferred through the media, Project PM focuses primarily on media reform. Our first and foremost effort has been to establish a distributed media cartel made up of bloggers as well as journalists who work at least in part through online media. Rather than simply assembling this group of exceptional media professionals into an online outlet similar to those currently in existence, we are instead organizing our participants into a network which itself operates under a unique schematic designed to take best advantage of the internet as a medium while simultaneously avoiding the drawbacks common to even the best online communities.

In order to seed the network, we have recruited around two dozen bloggers and journalists whom we have identified as particularly competent and intellectually honest. Each of these individuals is encouraged to bring other bloggers into the network based on their own judgment; these new participants are then connected to the blogger who has brought them in and may likewise bring others into the network,and so on . As such, the network grows perpetually while maintaining a high average quality in terms of its participants, as is explained further below.
Upon the launch of our network, each of the initial bloggers will be connected to each other via a widget which is embedded on their respective blogs, as well as connected to those whom they’ve recruited. When a particular individual composes a piece of work that he considers to be of particular merit, the individual pushes a single button which causes the article in question to be sent to all of the bloggers to whom he is connected. Each of those bloggers in turn then decides whether or not they agree that the article is worthy of greater attention; if so, they push the button and thereby send it along to every blogger to whom they themselves are connected. Thus it is that information deemed worthy of attention by some great number of erudite and honest individuals from a variety of backgrounds will tend to perpetuate through the system and gain a larger audience than they might otherwise receive.

As the network expands by way of the process described above, it is inevitable that there will be failures of judgement on the part of participants when choosing additional bloggers to bring into the network. Let us say that Blogger X, who is rather competent, brings in Blogger Y, who is only moderately so, and who in turn brings in Blogger Z, who is a giant douchebag. Blogger Z begins composing and pushing forward posts to the effect that Barack Obama was born in Tehran or that ethanol subsidies are awesome or some such thing – but these posts only initially go to Blogger Y and whatever horrid bloggers Blogger Z has brought in himself, assuming he has brough in any. Blogger Y may or may not be inclined to push forward these nonsense posts, but Blogger X will almost certainly delete them immediately and is quite likely to disolve his connection to Blogger Y for displaying such poor judgement. Thus it is that the system is defended from deterioration by the high competence of the initial round of bloggers and consequently comparable competence of those brought in gradually afterwards, coupled with the nature of the schematic itself. No supervision is necessary for the network to expand while maintaining a high level of quality.

A few other characteristics bear noting. Any participant may connect to any other participant who agrees to the connection, no matter “where” each participant resides in the network, and thus the network is likely to evolve from the shape of a pyramid to that of a web, which is advantageous in terms of ensuring that good information does not become overly “regionalized.” All participants are equal regardless of the order in which they joined. Participants are free to bring on as many other bloggers as they would like, although they will find that it is to their own advantage to be selective in this regard.

The system is capped off with another widget distinct from that used by the bloggers – the reader widget, a downloadable application which displays those posts which have been pushed forward a certain number of times (as set by the individual reader). The end result should be the best system of news and information filtration that has ever existed.
 


On Mon, Jul 12, 2010 at 9:55 PM, Henry Silverman <hsilverman@roosevelt.edu> wrote:
Hi Barrett.  I recently came across your January 22 column on Vanity Fair about Charles Johnson and your plan to launch a campaign to increase the reach and power of the blogosphere.  I currently edit a media watchdog blog and would be interested in learning more about your project if it is still on tap.

Looking forward to hearing from you.

Regards,

Henry


Henry I. Silverman, PhD
Chair: Finance, Real Estate, Accounting, Information Systems
Assistant Professor of Finance
Heller College of Business
Roosevelt University
430 S Michigan Avenue
Chicago, IL 60605
312-281-3319



--
Regards,

Barrett Brown
512-560-2302




--
Regards,

Barrett Brown
512-560-2302




--
Regards,

Barrett Brown
512-560-2302