black professor run out of Nashville with active support of Vanderbilt University for criticizing the founder of the KKK: background information
Subject: black professor run out of Nashville with active support of Vanderbilt University for criticizing the founder of the KKK: background information
From: Jonathan Farley <lattice.theory@gmail.com>
Date: 10/15/09, 13:03
To: Barett Brown <barriticus@gmail.com>

Dr. Farley-

Thanks for writing.

What happened to you in 2002 and the years since is perfectly indicative of the fascist mentality that exists in this nation and which has long been concentrated among the heavily Judeo-Christian south. You are perfectly correct to note that the fascists of the Confederacy ought to have been executed down to the last man, and I say that as a Texan whose own ancestors were among them. Either one is for the Enlightenment or he is not. The open secret of America is that some third of our citizens are not.

McCain's article on the aftermath of your column is terrible even for the Washington Times. It characterizes your violent detractors as merely "frustrated" and minimizes the threats you received with the transparently stupid phrasing "complained," as if this were something you were simply whining about as opposed to a verifiable fact.

I want to hit McCain on this immediately. I'd also like permission to reprint these threatening and poorly-conceived e-mails. Please get back to me at your convenience.

Regards,

Barrett Brown
Brooklyn, NY
512-560-2302



*******************************************





Dear Mr. Brown:

I appreciate your email.  You have permission to republish the hate emails sent to me by the neo-Confederates. 

Attached and below, please find more information (in third person) related to the attack.  The attack could not have succeeded if non-neo-Confederates had not surrendered to them, such as the head of my university at the time (which I was forced to flee, and never return to, despite having a permanent job), Gordon Gee---now president of Ohio State University---his spokesman, Michael Schoenfeld (now at Duke University), the chairman of the Vanderbilt mathematics department, Mike Mihalik, and virtually the entire faculty of Vanderbilt University and black population of Nashville, including the NAACP up to the highest levels (the chairman and president of the national organization) and the Green Party (national steering committee members and other leaders, such as Mike Feinstein, Scott McLarty, and Annie Goeke, some of whose emails were indistinguishable from those of neo-Confederates). 

You can find a summary of the episode, with ancillary documents, here:
I was on Sirius radio too.

My contact information (which I would not like published, if you don't mind) is as follows: My Austrian cell phone is +43 650 910 7416 and my Skype ID is lattice.theory.  My direct office line is +43 732 2468 9143 and my direct home number is +43 (0) 732 2457 2408.  I'm not sure if any of these phones have voice mail, but if they do, I do not yet know how to retrieve messages.  I do have a US cell phone where messages can be left, although I check it rarely: +1 617 460 3656.  I am 6 hours ahead of you and happy to call you at your convenience.

Regards,
Jonathan Farley 

**************************************************************************

On November 20, 2002, Jonathan Farley wrote an essay in "The Tennessean" newspaper (the main newspaper of that part of the state of Tennessee where the city of Nashville is) criticizing the man commonly referred to as the founder of the Ku Klux Klan, Nathan Bedford Forrest.  Forrest was a slave trader before the American Civil War, and during it massacred black prisoners of war, as well as women and children, at Fort Pillow. A relatively recent statue had been erected honoring him in Nashville, paid for in part by public funds.  At the time Farley was a mathematics professor at Vanderbilt University, although Farley wrote the essay as a private individual.  He received several dozen death threats and several hundred hate messages, especially after the story (inaccurately described, as always) was on Fox News with Brit Hume. 
 
 
Gordon Gee, then Chancellor (i.e., the head) of Vanderbilt University, wrote an essay criticizing Farley in the Vanderbilt student newspaper (which is called "The Hustler") and in The Tennessean.  His spokesman, Vice Chancellor Michael Schoenfeld, made even harsher public comments criticizing Farley.  The Tennessean two weeks in a row ran a full page of attacks on Farley (there was exactly one letter to the editor that was not an attack, written by the black Reverend Enoch Fuzz, and it was neutral), along with numerous articles that libeled Farley or otherwise attacked him.
 
In turn, the Black Student Alliance at Vanderbilt demanded that Schoenfeld "publicly retract and apologize for his racist remarks."  (See the attached letter from Black Student Alliance president Nia Toomer; Toomer also appeared on the popular "Tavis Smiley Show" prior to this, although her name is misspelled in the show's transcript.  After Tim Chavez, a conservative columnist for The Tennessean, published Nia's name in his column, explicitly to punish her for supporting Farley, she received a death threat and stopped making statements in support of Farley.)
 
At no point did any representative of Vanderbilt criticize Nathan Bedford Forrest, the Confederacy, the individuals sending Farley death threats, or contemporary "neo-Confederate" groups that honor the Confederacy, such as the United Daughters of the Confederacy, a group that was at that time suing Vanderbilt University.  (The victory of the UDC over Vanderbilt made the New York Times in July 2005.)  Indeed, the UDC took legal action against Farley solely and explicitly because of his essay.  Farley fled Nashville in early January 2003, leaving many of his belongings behind, including his Oxford graduation gown and books.
 
A number of stories were written in The Tennessean, which one can find with search engines such as Lexis Nexis.  This story was picked up by Associated Press, the Washington Times newspaper (the article was written by Associate Editor Robert Stacy McCain, a member of the League of the South, although this fact was not publicized)
and Fox News with Brit Hume, but the focus was always on this man Farley who criticized the Confederacy and so was clearly in the wrong, and indeed, crazy, and not Gee or Schoenfeld or the neo-Confederates.  Farley's reputation was destroyed, with predictable and enduring consequences.

For more background information on the United Daughters of the Confederacy, you can look at the site of the Southern Poverty Law Center.
(See the bottom of this webpage)
  
Farley's partial description of what happened to him can be found at the end of this essay:
 
The Guardian newspaper (Great Britain), on-line
 
The Nation Magazine's John Nichols is referring to Farley in the third paragraph from the end of this article about Trent Lott, former Senate Majority Leader.
 
The Council of Conservative Citizens' president, Gordon Baum, attacked Farley on NPR.  Here is the editorial that was written by CCC.  (Note that, contrary to what they write, Farley's father is Guyanese and his mother is Jamaican.)
 
Vanderbilt Math Teacher Spews Vitriol Over Confederacy
 
 
Vanderbilt professor Johnathan Farley was educated at Harvard and Oxford, but his simple-minded tirades against the Confederacy indicate how low prestigious universities will stoop to dole out fancy degrees to blacks. Perhaps he received his PHD in mathematics when he stopped counting his fingers to do arithmetic.
 
 
The angry backlash from the decision by Vanderbilt administrators to change the name of Confederate Memorial Hall triggered some bloodthirsty instincts in Farley. He beat the war drum in the local Nashville press, where he fumed that "Every Confederate soldier deserved not a hallowed resting place at the end of his days but a reservation at the end of the gallows."
 
 
Caught up in the wind of his own fury, Farley went on to brand General Nathan Bedford Forrest as "a 19th century Hitler," and compared United Daughters of the Confederacy to holocaust revisionists.
 
 
Farley's bulge-eyed outbursts might be dismissed as the sort of primal screeching heard from the street pulpits of Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton. The difference is that Jonathan Farley is supposed to have the keen, calculating mind befitting a mathematics professor. Instead, he raves like an African potentate shaking his spear at the remnants of white colonialism.
 
 
"The race problems that wrack America to this day," says Farley, "are due largely to the fact that the Confederacy was not thoroughly destroyed, its leaders and soldiers executed, and their lands given to the landless freed slaves."
 
 
In the aftermath of the war against the South, many prominent Northerners had a higher opinion of the Confederacy than Farley does.
 
 
In a Decoration Day speech in 1885, one old Civil War veteran described "the ability and virtues of Robert E. Lee" as "a part of the common heritage of glory of all the people of America."  No unrepentant rebel, the man who spoke those words was Gen. George McClellan, once commander of the Union Army of the Potomac. Who is Jonathan Farley to say different?
 
 
Truth is that Jonathan Farley is not really an American himself, and he expresses much the same contempt for America that he harbors towards the South. The son of a Jamaican father and African mother- both academics- Farley idolizes murderous Marxist revolutionaries like Che Guevara.
 
 
If not American, what is Jonathan Farley? He is the egocentric spawn of pampered black immigrants who has spent his life licking up the cream of white institutions, then hissing back at his benefactors as thanks for their colorblind philanthropy. In other words, he is the quintessential citizen of the global village.
 
 
And since the global village is mostly nonwhite, Farley acts as a third world janissary for black hegemony over whites. His attitude differs little from the seething hordes who rampage over civilization to loot and burn what their crude minds cannot appreciate.
 
 
Farley is one of those malcontent who lives among people he envies and despises so he can harangue those he considers inferior. As a protected species in the cozy domain of a posh university, Farley has plenty of idle time to invent mischief .
 
 
Farley is everything he presumes to detest: a crass, condescending elitist who lords over the white untouchables squatting outside the manor gates.
 
 
Predictably, Vanderbilt officials rushed to Farley's defense.

The university says Farley can say anything he wants without fear of losing his job.
 
 
To be sure, if Farley was white and posed in front of a poster of Nathan Bedford Forrest, he would be off the Vanderbilt campus before sundown.
 
 
Perhaps we Southerners should take a cue from the seething, third world masses who scorned American Imperialism in the bygone days of Che Guevara.
 
 
Let's gather a mob at Vanderbilt and shout

"YANKEE GO HOME!"                              -- Editor.
 
 
 
Something similar happened to white Princeton University historian James McPherson. 
The description of then-Chancellor of Vanderbilt University, Gordon Gee, can be found in Chapter 2 of the attached document.  His statements about wanting to protect Farley's academic freedom are false.  Further, he refers to neo-Confederate groups such as the UDC as "old friends".  You can find more about the UDC's support of the KKK here.  The UDC's KKK postcard is especially telling. (There are additional supporting documents.)
 
Gordon Gee is now president of Ohio State University.
 
 
 
The death threat Gee refers to is described in the following article from The Tennessean.  (The description of Farley or Farley's views near the end of this article is not necessarily correct.)   

Tennessean, The (Nashville, TN)

Tennessean, The (Nashville, TN)

January 17, 2003

Dorm name change led to threats to VU

Author: MICHAEL CASS
Section: Main News
Page: 1A

Article Text:

Caller vows to cut out Gee's heart, school reports

By MICHAEL CASS

Staff Writer

One person called Vanderbilt University's chancellor and threatened to "cut (his) heart out" another e-mailed a university spokeswoman to threaten an event involving former Vice President Al Gore. Both threats came after the school decided to remove the word "Confederate" from a building's name, Vanderbilt says in court documents.

Vanderbilt attorneys attached copies of e-mail messages, a campus police report and a police official's affidavit to a memorandum filed in Davidson County Chancery Court late Wednesday afternoon. They included the items to counter the United Daughters of the Confederacy's claim that the university had shown no specific examples of threats to Vanderbilt personnel when it asked the court to seal documents related to the decision.

Attorneys for the two sides will debate that request before Davidson County Chancellor Irvin Kilcrease at 9 a.m. today.

The UDC's Tennessee division sued Vanderbilt in October over its plans to change the name of Confederate Memorial Hall, a dormitory that the organization helped build with a $50,000 donation nearly 70 years ago. On Jan. 3, Vanderbilt asked the court to keep confidential any documents revealing the names of administrators, trustees and other people involved in the decision.

After the UDC responded last week, Vanderbilt offered a much longer argument in support of its position, claiming that the lawsuit "concerns matters .... of little legitimate public interest (the changing of the name of a dormitory on a private university's campus)."

"First of all, it should be clear that there is no 'public right to know' regarding factual information relevant to this case," the Wednesday filing states. "Vanderbilt University is a private, not-for-profit institution. Despite its prominence in the Nashville community, Vanderbilt has ... no legal obligation to disclose or report to the public any of its decision-making processes."

The attached police report, listing Vanderbilt Chancellor Gordon Gee as the victim, says Gee returned a call from Wallace Earl Cook of 1437 Nesbitt Drive in Madison on Jan. 7. "After Gee explained the reason for the name change, subject Cook stated that he was through talking and was going to come over to Vanderbilt to cut Gee's heart out," says the report, filed later that day.

Charles V. Smith, Vanderbilt's assistant chief of police, says in the affidavit that "VUPD investigated Cook and learned that he is a retired military service member. No criminal record on him could be located. VUPD continues to provide increased security for the Chancellor, (administration building) Kirkland Hall and other locations as a result of this incident."

Cook could not be reached for comment yesterday.

One of the e-mail messages, addressed to a Vanderbilt spokeswoman and sent by a Jean Stork on Oct. 18, contains the subject line "Removal of 'Confederate' from building 'bad' ... Gore address 'worse.' "

"Shame on you all," the message reads in part. "We only hope you have plenty of security around for this distastfull event .... As we fear you will need it."

Gore and his wife, Tipper, spoke at Vanderbilt's annual Family Re-Union conference on Oct. 21. Smith's affidavit says a VUPD detective determined that the message had come from out of state and that there were no problems during the conference.

Other e-mails contain a mix of racial slurs, criticisms of Gee, a reference to the university as "Panderguilt" and other insults. One, from a Henry Maston, expresses the hope that Gee will be "killed by the same worthless (racial slur) that kills Farley."

Jonathan Farley, an assistant math professor at Vanderbilt, wrote in a column published in The Tennessean in November that Confederate soldiers and leaders should have been executed at the end of the Civil War. In a related matter, Vanderbilt and UDC attorneys are arguing over whether the UDC needs to depose, or interview, Farley, who will begin a visiting professorship at Massachusetts Institute of Technology this month.

According to Smith's affidavit, two Davidson County assistant district attorneys told a VUPD detective that "there were no specific threats that warranted prosecution" in Maston's message.

*************************************************************
 

 
 
Vanderbilt spokesman Michael Schoenfeld's comments in The Vanderbilt Hustler (below) were repeated in The Tennessean
 
Schoenfeld is now at Duke University.