Subject: RE: Media Request for Article on Life Cycle Assessments |
From: "Nana Wilberforce" <nwilberforce@greenseal.org> |
Date: 5/22/08, 11:38 |
To: "Barrett Brown" <barriticus@gmail.com> |
Hello Barrett
As a start I will try to answer your
questions in the manner you presented in your previous email
Q: I was hoping you might be
able to provide me with some examples of allegedly "green" products
and services that don't actually possess favorable LCA's or are otherwise not
quite what they're cracked up to be?
A: the answer to this question may be biodiesel. There is a lot
of noise about biofuels being renewable and therefore green. However recent lca
research has shown that not all biofuels per se can reduce environmental impacts
as compared to fossil fuels. Currently of all the production paths investigated,
it is especially the use of biogenic wastes and grass to wood that brings a
reduction in the environmental impact as compared with fossil fuels. Also there
is a new buzz about clean coal, but a critical look will show you that coal is
not green.
Q: I was also curious to know if someone at
your organization be willing to give me a quick quote about what to look for
when assessing the LCA of the products they use
A: When conducting an lca of products from different
companies, the entire life cycle of the product should be considered. First the
acquisition of raw materials and types of raw materials used in production
(renewable resource, recycled raw materials etc). Secondly the production
processes should also be considered (energy use, raw materials used, and
emissions from production which may be hazardous). Thirdly you have to look at
the product use phase ( how long can the product be used, how many times must
repairs be made or parts be replaced, how much energy does the product require,
does the product contain harmful chemicals that will be hazardous to the user).
Lastly you have to also look at the end of life of the product (what percentage
of the product is recyclable, what percentage contain harmful chemicals and how
those chemicals are disposed off, what types of waste management does the
product require).
In all the concept of sustainability must be taken into consideration
I hope I have been able to give you some answers to your question
Regards
Dr. Nana Takyi Wilberforce
Environmental Scientist
Green Seal
202-872-6400
nwilberforce@greenseal.org
www.greenseal.org
From: Barrett Brown
[mailto:
Sent: Wednesday, May 21, 2008 5:02
PM
To:
Subject: Re: Media Request for
Article on Life Cycle Assessments
Nana-
Thanks for getting back to me. Tomorrow will be absolutely fine. I look forward
to getting your e-mail, and thanks in advance for your assistance.
Regards,
Barrett Brown
On Wed, May 21, 2008 at 4:40 PM,
Hello barrett
I just got your email about the lca. I can provide some
answers for you hopefully tomorrow morning
Will that be fine with you? Today is kind of a busy day but
tomorrow will be fine with me
nana
Dr. Nana Takyi Wilberforce
Environmental Scientist
Green Seal
202-872-6400
nwilberforce@greenseal.org
www.greenseal.org
From: Barrett Brown [mailto:barriticus@gmail.com]
Sent: Wednesday, May 21, 2008 2:59
PM
To: Green Seal
Subject: Media Request for Article
on Life Cycle Assessments
Sirs-
Howdy. I'm a freelance
writer and I'm working on an article for a new trade publication that serves
the convention display design and production industry. The piece concerns the
manner in which those involved in this and related fields can minimize the
environmental impact of their industry without being taken in by those firms
which purport to offer green options while ignoring legitimate barometers of
impact such as Life Cycle Assessment.
I've done a bit of research
on your organization and I'd like to mention it in the article as a good place
to start for those who are new to green purchasing or who would like to become
certified themselves. I was also curious to know if someone at your
organization be willing to give me a quick quote about what to look for when
assessing the LCA of the products they use. More importantly, I was hoping you
might be able to provide me with some examples of allegedly "green"
products and services that don't actually possess favorable LCA's or are
otherwise not quite what they're cracked up to be.
If you can provide me
with a quick quote or put me in touch with someone who might be able to, please
get back to me later today if possible.
Thanks,
Barrett Brown
512-560-2302